Current:Home > reviewsUnfortunate. That describes Joel Embiid injury, games played rule, and NBA awards mess -EquityZone
Unfortunate. That describes Joel Embiid injury, games played rule, and NBA awards mess
View
Date:2025-04-23 06:01:33
The entire Joel Embiid situation is unfortunate.
That’s the best word for it.
Unfortunate that Embiid, the Philadelphia 76ers star, is injured, first and foremost.
Unfortunate that Embiid’s injury puts him in the middle of a controversy surrounding a new rule tying games played to eligibility for regular-season awards and honors such as MVP and All-NBA.
Unfortunate that Embiid was slammed with over-the-top hot takes when he didn’t play against Denver because of a legitimate injury as opposed to him “ducking” Nuggets star Nikola Jokic.
Unfortunate that injuries have been conflated with load management – sitting out with an injury is not the same as taking a game off for no good reason.
The NBA knew this would happen, a situation where an All-Star caliber player would be ineligible for a major award because he didn’t play in at least 65 of 82 games.
No one could’ve predicted it would happen so soon in the first season with the new rule in place, adopted by the league and players in the 2023 collective bargaining agreement.
It’s a fascinating topic with tight curves and steep slopes – and a slew of opinions.
Embiid, the 2022-23 MVP, is having another dominant season, averaging a career-high 35.3 points and 5.7 assists. He also can be counted on for 11.3 rebounds, 1.8 blocks and 1.1 steals and shoots 53.3% from the field, 36.6% on 3-pointers and 88.3% on free throws.
Even before his latest injury – a meniscus issue in his left knee sustained Tuesday against Golden State – Embiid was headed for a potential season with less than 65 games played. He has missed 13 games and will miss Saturday’s against Brooklyn as the team, Embiid and knee specialists determine the best treatment plan. He’s sure to miss even more.
It’s difficult to envision Embiid playing 65 games and being a part of the MVP conversation the rest of the season.
Why did the NBA and players implement this rule? Was it necessary to tie games played to awards and honors? Why was 65 the magic number?
The league has made a dedicated effort to get its best players on the court for as many games as possible, including the implementation of a Player Participation Policy which encourages teams to play healthy star players or risk a fine. The NBA is an entertainment business, too, and paying customers (fans, TV partners, sponsors) want to see the best product possible. There’s nothing wrong with that.
Since the league can’t fine a player – just the team – when he misses a game, the NBA wanted an incentive for players. That’s why there’s a minimum games played required for those awards and honors.
For the most part, the media has policed games played in relation to awards throughout the years. Bill Walton has the fewest games played for any MVP at 58 games in 1977-78, but that’s when players voted for MVP. Since 1980-81, media has voted for MVP.
More:Why Joel Embiid's astounding stats might not be enough for him to win NBA MVP
When Embiid won the award last season and played in 66 games, it was the fewest games played for an MVP since 1980-81. Allen Iverson is the next MVP with the fewest games played in a season at 71 in 2000-2001. Every other MVP since 1980-81 has played in at least 72 games.
But this gives the media a hard line. There’s no arbitrary number from one voter to the next. For example, some people didn’t vote for LeBron James as an All-NBA selection last season because they didn’t think he played in enough games (55). But other voters did, and he made the team. Now, there's no confusion on what it takes to be considered.
But why 65 games? That’s essentially 80% of games (79.268% to be exact), and it is reasonable to think a player should play in 80% of games to be MVP or All-NBA. Could it have been 60 or 62 games? Sure. But the league and players settled on 65, and there doesn’t seem to be a movement, at least right now, for revisiting that number.
This may impact a small percentage of players but it has an outsized importance based on those involved, especially when you include Indiana Pacers guard Tyrese Haliburton who is having an All-NBA season. He averages 23.0 points and a league-best 12.3 assists while shooting 49.2% from the field and 39.5% on 3-pointers.
In the offseason, Haliburton signed a five-year, $205.9 million designated max extension, but if he were to make All-NBA this season, the amount would grow to $246 million. Because of a hamstring injury, he has missed 13 games. The stakes are significant.
There’s not much recourse for Embiid or Haliburton. There is a grievance process, but those are aimed at extraordinary circumstances which force a player to miss games (birth, death) or a team possibly limiting minutes and games played in an effort to suppress a player’s chances to earn a higher salary.
Embiid, who has an extensive injury history and has played in 65 or more games just twice in seven seasons, wants to play and win. He has said his goal is to win an NBA title, and the Sixers are just 4-9 without him this season. He knows they need him on the court.
And his desire to be on the court – for a variety of reasons – when perhaps he should have been sidelined led to an injury.
And an unfortunate situation all the way around.
Follow Jeff Zillgitt on social media @JeffZillgitt
veryGood! (29)
Related
- Federal appeals court upholds $14.25 million fine against Exxon for pollution in Texas
- Black leaders call out Trump’s criminal justice contradictions as he rails against guilty verdict
- World War II veterans take off for France for 80th anniversary of D-Day
- Oregon defendants without a lawyer must be released from jail, US appeals court says
- Jamie Foxx gets stitches after a glass is thrown at him during dinner in Beverly Hills
- Whoopi Goldberg makes rare Friday appearance on 'The View' for Donald Trump guilty verdict
- Feds charge retired 4-star Navy admiral in alleged bribery scheme
- Mike Tyson-Jake Paul fight postponed due to Tyson’s ulcer flare-up
- Jorge Ramos reveals his final day with 'Noticiero Univision': 'It's been quite a ride'
- 2 killed, 3 injured when stolen SUV crashes during pursuit in Vermont
Ranking
- Senate begins final push to expand Social Security benefits for millions of people
- Taylor Momsen Shares Terrifying Moment She Was Bitten by Bat During Concert
- The Top 12 Must-Have Lululemon Gifts for Father's Day 2024
- Kyra Sedgwick and the lighter side of disability in All of Me
- Tarte Shape Tape Concealer Sells Once Every 4 Seconds: Get 50% Off Before It's Gone
- Black leaders call out Trump’s criminal justice contradictions as he rails against guilty verdict
- Nevada State Primary Election Testing, Advisory
- University of the Arts abruptly announces June 7 closure, vows to help students transfer
Recommendation
A Mississippi company is sentenced for mislabeling cheap seafood as premium local fish
Oregon utility regulator rejects PacifiCorp request to limit its liability in wildfire lawsuits
Dance Moms Alum Kelly Hyland Reveals How Her Kids Are Supporting Her Through Cancer Treatments
2 killed, 3 injured when stolen SUV crashes during pursuit in Vermont
Macy's says employee who allegedly hid $150 million in expenses had no major 'impact'
UVA to pay $9 million related to shooting that killed 3 football players, wounded 2 students
100 years ago, US citizenship for Native Americans came without voting rights in swing states
Gabbriette Bechtel Shares Rare Insight Into Relationship With Matty Healy